The iniquities exposed by the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry make depressingly
familiar reading to the drug using community. Sir William Macpherson stated
that thoughtlessness, ignorance, insensitivity and stereotyping were issues
for all public institutions.
The
teaching profession admitted to underachievement and high exclusion rates
for ethnic minority children as endemic in education as elsewhere, and
the legal profession as a whole was reluctant to accept that racism might
be an institutional problem, although none of the 98 High Court judges
come from ethnic minorities. The media, represented by Tim Gopsill (National
Union of Journalists) admitted woeful under representation of black people
in media and racist overtones in many national newspapers.
Systemic
discrimination through ignorance, prejudice and stereotyping is not just
bad practice. As we have tragically seen in the Lawrence case, it is positively
dangerous and can lead to appalling social injustice, injury and death.
In the first edition of Black Poppy (Dec '98), I claimed that 'pejorative
language, partial facts, lies, spurious research plus downright hypocrisy
are leading us ever backwards into a war strategy and a structure of prejudice
that helps to justify neglect and medical ineptitude and ignore the ever
rising health problems and death toll amongst drug users.' As recently
as 1996, the Oxford Textbook of Medicine stated that the explicit prejudice
against patients with drug related physical problems can result in unacceptable
practice. For example, it noted a case of a hospital doctor writing in
the medical notes that a severely ill young IVDU should not be resuscitated
or another example, where a young former IVDU with infective endocarditis
was not considered for valve replacement, solely on the grounds of his
history of drug problems. It went on '.....such dubious clinical practice
is frequently based on ignorance, lack of experience, and a failure to
consider the ethical implications of withholding lifesaving treatment...The
concept that such individuals have a right to treatment is not yet readily
accepted...'¹
The
consequences of devaluing drug users in this way should be a grave concern
to us all. It certainly ensures that they will continue to be excluded
from the drugs discourse where their experience and their expertise are
needed most urgently. How can any change occur if the current stereotypes
of drug users are constantly reinforced by the mass media; inculcated
throughout drugs education, the NHS, treatment centres, Social Services,
the Police, and remain totally devoid of all political will to challenge
them?
"Britain
was conspicuous by its absence from a Europe wide movement trying to emphasise
harm reduction as a way of tackling problems" writes Ian Traynor
(the Guardian 26/10/98). He goes on.. "A full page advert in the
New York Times in June declared 'We believe that the global war on drugs
is now causing more harm than drug abuse itself". Signed by a global
elite of government, political, academic and public figures, the declaration
was drafted by a small band of experts in Frankfurt who have established
a network across European cities to lobby for international coordination
on drugs policy. The European Cities on Drug Policy Network, initiated
by four women politicians from Germany, The Netherlands and Switzerland
in 1990, spans 31 cities in 10 countries. Unfortunately, no British cities
got involved.
As
the Lawrences discovered, black voices have been raised for very many
years, but have not been heard until now. As Mrs Lawrence said, perhaps
if they had been white, it would have been quicker.
In fact, it wasn't until the media got over their shock that the Lawrences
didn't stand up to the usual black stereotypes that their story became
really newsworthy. The terrible effect of pre-existing prejudice and negative
attitudes have now been spelt out by this damning report and its full
impact experienced by the Lawrence family and other families who have
lost their loved ones in similar circumstances. The Lawrences felt silenced
by their colour. We know colour is not the only thing that silences people.
How many drug users, or their families, dare to risk public ignominy to
speak about their treatment in the hands of our public and corporate institutions?